Why confidence is becoming the missing ingredient in supply chain assurance
Food businesses have more tools than ever for documenting their supply chains. Supplier approval programmes, traceability records, certification schemes and digital platforms can provide detailed visibility of how products move from source to customer.
On paper, that should inspire confidence.
But visibility and verification are not the same thing.
A Europe-wide investigation led by Belgian authorities, with Europol support, recently examined suspected falsification of horse passports and manipulation of animal identity records. At the centre of the case were concerns that existing records and identifiers had been altered to obscure animals’ true identities and histories, rather than simply an absence of documentation.
While the circumstances are specific to the equine sector, the underlying challenge is not.
The case raises a question that applies to almost every modern supply chain: if confidence in the information begins to erode, how much confidence should we place in the systems built upon it?
Traceability was never designed to create certainty
Traceability remains one of the most important foundations of food assurance.
Traceability helps businesses identify where products came from and where they were supplied, supporting accountability and targeted action when problems occur (Codex, 2006). It remains a foundation of assurance, even when additional checks are needed.
However, traceability was never intended to provide absolute certainty.
At its core, traceability is an information-management system. It records what has been declared, documented and communicated as products move from one stage of the chain to the next. It creates visibility and helps establish provenance based on the information available.
What it does not necessarily do is independently verify that the information itself is correct. An FSA-commissioned review describes analytical methods for checking origin against paper-based traceability, while stressing that no single technique provides an unequivocal answer in every case.
Supplier checks, complete records and successful audits provide important assurance. But the existence of controls and the independent corroboration of a particular claim are different questions.
Increasingly, stakeholders are asking not only whether information exists, but how much confidence exists in that information.
Why confidence is becoming a bigger issue
Food supply chains are increasingly complex. Ingredients may pass through processors, traders and intermediaries across multiple countries, with information generated at one stage relied upon by businesses several stages removed from the original source.
At the same time, claims around provenance, sustainability, responsible sourcing and authenticity carry growing commercial significance.
A business may therefore have extensive documentation and a complete traceability trail, yet still face a more difficult question if the underlying information is challenged.
The issue is no longer simply whether a product can be traced. It is whether the information being traced can be trusted.
Soy provides a useful example of the challenge
Few commodities illustrate the challenge more clearly than soy. Global supply chains can involve multiple growers, traders, storage facilities, processors and manufacturers before material reaches the final customer.
Deforestation legislation has brought renewed attention to these issues. European Commission guidance on the EUDR makes clear that certification can complement, but cannot substitute for, an operator’s due diligence responsibility. The challenge is therefore not just collecting information, but assessing whether it is reliable.
This is where independent evidence can add another layer of assurance. At Bia Analytical, more than 1,000 soybean samples from 21 countries have been analysed as part of work exploring country-of-origin assessment at scale. Separately, peer-reviewed research has demonstrated the potential for analytical approaches to discriminate soybean origin, adding independent evidence that scientific verification can complement documentary traceability.
Origin testing does not replace traceability or demonstrate farm-level origin or deforestation-free status. What it can do is provide another source of evidence against which a declared origin can be assessed.
From visibility to confidence
Traceability and verification perform different roles.
Traceability provides visibility. It helps organisations understand how products move through supply chains, where they originate and which suppliers are involved.
Verification adds another layer of confidence by testing whether key claims relating to identity, origin or composition are consistent with independent evidence.
One does not replace the other. The practical aim is to connect visibility with evidence, choosing checks that address the claim being made rather than assuming that one record or test can answer every question.
That leads to a useful question for any food business:
If one of your sourcing, provenance or authenticity claims were challenged tomorrow, what evidence would you rely on to support it?
At Bia Analytical, we help food businesses add independent scientific evidence to the traceability and assurance systems they already rely on.
Because when questions are asked of your supply chain, documentation explains the process that was followed.
Evidence is what supports the position.